The Falcons were dealt a significant blow when it became clear they would need to put starting right tackle Kaleb McGary on season-ending injured reserve. Veteran Elijah Wilkinson was McGary’s immediate replacement in practice, and D. Orlando Ledbetter of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution confirms Wilkinson will open the season as the club’s starting RT.
With southpaw Michael Penix Jr. at quarterback, Atlanta’s right tackle position is particularly important. McGary, who recently inked a two-year extension keeping him under club control through 2027, has not earned any Pro Bowl accolades like left tackle Jake Matthews and right guard Chris Lindstrom, but he has established himself as an above-average tackle, particularly in terms of run-blocking.
Plus, as Penix enters his first full season as a starter, stability along the O-line would be welcome. While the Falcons return Matthews, Lindstrom, and left guard Matthew Bergeron, they lost center Drew Dalman in free agency this offseason and will rely upon Ryan Neuzil – a 2021 UDFA who has eight career starts – as Penix’s full-time snapper. Team brass thinks highly of Neuzil, though he was not particularly impressive as an injury fill-in for Dalman last year.
Instead of replacing just one starting O-lineman, Atlanta will be forced to replace two. And it is quite possible there will be a noticeable drop-off in performance with Wilkinson on the first-team unit in lieu of McGary. This will be Wilkinson’s second Falcons stint; he played as a nine-game guard starter in 2022.
Now 30, Wilkinson does have 45 starts to his name, but his last start at right tackle came in 2021, when he was with the Bears. The well-traveled blocker started nine games at left guard for the Cardinals in 2023 and earned an abysmal 46.2 overall grade from Pro Football Focus, one of the worst marks in the league. Arizona released him during final roster cutdowns last August, and though he quickly caught on with the Falcons’ taxi squad, he ultimately appeared in just two games for the team and played one offensive snap. Wilkinson did serve as the Broncos’ primary RT in 2019 and added seven more starts at the position in 2020. For most of this decade, however, teams have employed the eight-year veteran as a backup.
The Falcons at least saw enough from Wilkinson to re-sign him this offseason – albeit on a veteran-minimum salary – and they used him at left tackle in their second preseason contest. He indicated he is looking forward to playing alongside Lindstrom, and Lindstrom’s presence certainly could help elevate Wilkinson’s play.
If Wilkinson is not up to snuff, Atlanta has recent trade acquisition Michael Jerrell waiting in the wings, and veteran swing tackle Storm Norton could be an option later in the season. Placed on short-term IR this week, Norton recently underwent ankle surgery and is expected to miss at least the first month of the 2025 campaign.